The Problem Of Mill s Theory - 1410 Words

1. Read the following case study. Write a 300-500 word essay explaining what you think Mill would advise Sarah to do in this situation and why. (Please note that there may not be only one correct answer to this question. You will be graded on how you apply Mill’s thinking to the case and defend the decision you think he would advocate.) The situation Sarah faces is a tough ethical dilemma coming from any perspective. This includes the perspective of utility. While I have no idea what Mill himself would have suggested Sarah do, I do believe that if we follow his line of thought we are presented with an answer. Admittedly, good logic could arrive at either possible answer and perhaps this is the greatest flaw of Mill’s theory. In any case, taking all things into consideration, given my lack of knowledge regarding details of this hypothetical situation, I believe that Mill would endorse Sarah if she gave the money to pay for the treatment. While a simple understanding of utilitarianism may lead one to think that Mill would not encourage Sarah to pay for the treatment, however I believe the opposite is true. Were Sarah to refuse to pay the fee, and spend the money continuing the initiative she had started, there would certainly be a short term benefit. However, the value of having an activist, who understands the culture and the complexity of the issue from a first-hand perspective would be greater. Now we cannot be certain whether this girl who Sarah is helping will turn intoShow MoreRelatedCharles Wright Mills And The American Sociological Review Essay934 Words   |  4 PagesC.Wright Mills or Charles Wright Mills was born on August 28, 1916 in Texas. He attended the University of Texas where he got his bachelor s degree in 1939. Before even graduating, Mills had already been published in the two leading sociology journals in the United States, the American Journal of Sociology and the American Sociological Review. After his bachelors degree, he pursued his Ph.D at the University of Wisconsin in 1941. During his time in Wisconsin, he met his wife, Dorothy Helen SmithRead MoreUtilitarianism : The Utilitarian Moral Theory Essay968 Words   |  4 PagesUtilitarianism-Module 5 1. In its general form, what is the utilitarian moral theory? In its general form, the utilitarian moral theory advocates that an action is morally right if it serves the greatest good for the greatest amount of people. 2. What is hedonism, and what is hedonistic utilitarianism? And, what was Epicurus s view about pleasure? Hedonsim is the principle that suggests that pleasure is the motivator of one’s life and hedonistic utilitarianism is when ethics is determinedRead MoreBoth Mill And Nietzsche Would Argue That The Singularity1342 Words   |  6 PagesBoth Mill and Nietzsche would argue that the singularity of values, or preconceived, undivided ideas of truth, is an impediment to freedom. Nietzsche’s perspective further details how utility theory, as a method to determine freedom, inhibits freedom, as it appears to support the singularity of values. He would argue that prescribing a moral good of utility and saying that it is good for society as a whole, is promoting cultural specificity in that it assumes that one idea is good for everyone. NietzscheRead MoreThe Sociological Imagination By C. Wright Mills1315 Words   |  6 Pagessociety. This is its task and its promise.† C. Wright Mills writes about the sociological imagination in an attempt to have society become aware of t he relationship between one’s personal experience in comparison to the wider society. By employing the sociological imagination into the real world, individuals are forced to perceive, from a neutral position, social structures that, in turn, influence behavior, attitudes, and culture. Mills just wants the world to be able to see the connection betweenRead MoreSociological Imagination s Critical Review1319 Words   |  6 Pagessociety. This is its task and its promise.† C. Wright Mills writes about the sociological imagination in an attempt to have society become aware of the relationship between one’s personal experience in comparison to the wider society. By employing the sociological imagination into the real world, individuals are forced to perceive, from a neutral position, social structures that, in turn, influence behavior, attitudes, and culture. Mills just wants the world to be able to see the connection betweenRead MoreKey Features of Utilitarian ism Essay1189 Words   |  5 Pages(21) The theory of Utilitarianism is based on the concept of utility, a theory of usefulness. Utilitarianism is a system of morality that generates us with what the most useful thing to do in different situations and outcomes. Different Utilitarian approaches to morality have emerged each with their own theory of good and community of concerning individuals. Featuring the main influential contributors to this theory are Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill. There are two types of theories, teleologicalRead MoreJohn Forbes Nash Jr.912 Words   |  4 PagesJohn Forbes Nash Jr. and John Stuart Mill were both very important economist. John Forbes Nash Jr. was an American mathematician, and an economist. John Mill was a British Philosopher, economist, moral and political theorist, and was the most influential English-speaking philosopher in the nineteenth century. John Forbes Nash Jr. and John Stuart Mill were both very intelligent as young children. John Stuart Mill learned to read as a toddl er and began to study Latin at the age of three. John ForbesRead MoreFord Pinto Case For A Defective Fuel System903 Words   |  4 PagesFORD PINTO ASSIGNMENT The Ford Pinto case involved the explosion of Ford Pinto s due to a defective fuel system. The fuel system was designed in a way that even with a small hit the car would explode. After the cost-benefit analysis, Ford decided to go with its original gas tank designed despite the crash-test result. At that time Ford thought that would be the most ethical decision for the business. But later in 1978 media paid more attention to the Pinto gas tank stories, which resulted in accidentsRead MoreThe Contributions Of John Stuart Mill1250 Words   |  5 PagesJohn Stuart Mill was a British philosopher who was born on May 20, 1806 in London, England, to Harriet Burrow and James Mill, a noted economist, philosopher and historian. James Mill was an educated man who was heavily involved in an early 19th century movement called philosophic radicalism, a school of thought also known as Utilitarianism, which highlighted the demand for a scientific foundation for philosophy, as well as a humanist a pproach to economics politics. It was this foundation fromRead MoreUtilitarianism, And Principle Of Utility1319 Words   |  6 Pagesappetites and, when once made conscious of them, do not regard anything as happiness which does not include their gratification.† (Mill, 332) There have been many philosophers who have taking up the topic of utilitarianism, but one that defines the quality of pleasures along with defining that there are actions behind picking those pleasures would be John Stuart Mill. Mill in his years of talking and discussing utilitarianism disagreed and agreed with philosophers and had a model. In this essay the